Mastering Workers’ Compensation Audits: A Definitive Guide

Workers’ compensation audits are reviews conducted by insurance companies to verify the accuracy of a business’s payroll and classification of employees, ensuring that the correct premium is being paid for workers’ compensation insurance. These audits can be performed annually or at the end of a policy term and are essential for maintaining compliance with state laws and regulations.

The process involves examining a company’s financial records, employment documents, and other relevant information to assess whether the amount of risk covered by the policy aligns with the premiums charged. The outcome of a workers’ compensation audit can result in adjustments to the insurance premium, either as additional charges or as refunds, depending on whether the initial estimates were higher or lower than the actual exposure.

Workers' Compensation Audits

Insurance Separator Red Line

Workers’ compensation insurance is a critical component of the employer-employee relationship, providing necessary protection for both parties in the event of a workplace injury. However, to ensure that the coverage accurately reflects the risks and payroll expenses of a company, insurers often conduct workers’ compensation audits. These audits can be daunting for employers, but understanding the process and preparing accordingly can make them a manageable part of doing business.

The initiation of a workers’ compensation audit typically occurs at the end of a policy term. Insurers require these audits to verify that the premium paid by the employer aligns with the actual payroll and job classifications of employees. Discrepancies between estimated and actual figures can result in additional premiums due or refunds to the employer. Therefore, it is imperative for businesses to maintain accurate records throughout the year to facilitate a smooth audit process.

As the audit approaches, employers should gather all necessary documentation. This includes payroll records, tax forms, and any other relevant financial statements. Additionally, detailed records of job descriptions and classifications are essential, as these determine the risk levels associated with different positions and consequently affect insurance rates. Employers should also prepare a list of subcontractors and independent contractors used during the policy period, along with certificates of insurance to prove that these entities had their own coverage.

During the audit, the auditor will review the collected documents and may ask for clarification or additional information. It is crucial for employers to be transparent and cooperative, as any attempt to withhold information can lead to penalties or a more extensive audit. Employers should also take this opportunity to ask questions and understand how the auditor arrived at their conclusions. This can provide valuable insights into how to better manage workers’ compensation costs in the future.

After the audit is completed, the employer will receive an audit report detailing the findings. If the audit reveals that the employer owes additional premiums, it is important to review the calculations and ensure they are accurate before making payment. If there are discrepancies or if the employer believes the audit is incorrect, they should not hesitate to dispute the findings with the insurer. Conversely, if the audit results in a refund, the employer should ensure that the amount is received in a timely manner.

Employers should also use the audit as a learning experience to improve their practices for the next policy period. This might include updating payroll systems to ensure accuracy, reviewing job classifications, and ensuring that all employees are correctly categorized. By proactively managing these aspects of their business, employers can minimize the risk of significant adjustments following future audits.

In conclusion, workers’ compensation audits are an essential part of maintaining a fair and accurate workers’ compensation insurance system. While they can be complex, employers who keep meticulous records and approach the process with diligence can navigate these audits successfully. By preparing thoroughly, cooperating with auditors, and using the findings to refine business practices, employers can not only endure the audit process but also emerge with a more efficient and cost-effective approach to workers’ compensation insurance.

Frequently Asked Questions

Insurance Separator Red Line

1. What is a workers’ compensation audit?

A workers’ compensation audit is a review of a business’s records and operations by an insurance company to ensure that the premium charged for workers’ compensation insurance accurately reflects the employer’s operations and the risks associated with the work performed by its employees.

2. Why is my business being audited?

Audits are a standard part of the workers’ compensation insurance process. Insurance companies conduct audits to verify that the payroll and class codes reported at the beginning of the policy period match the actual payroll and work performed.

3. What records will I need to provide during an audit?

You will typically need to provide payroll records, tax forms (such as W-2s and 1099s), your general ledger, cash disbursements, employee records, certificates of insurance for subcontractors, and any other documentation that verifies your payroll and the nature of your work.

4. How often do workers’ compensation audits occur?

Workers’ compensation audits usually occur annually, but some policies may require audits more frequently, especially if there are significant changes in your business operations or payroll.

5. Can I prepare for a workers’ compensation audit?

Yes, you can prepare by organizing your records, ensuring they are accurate and up-to-date, and understanding the details of your insurance policy, including the class codes and payroll estimates.

6. What happens if there are discrepancies found during the audit?

If discrepancies are found, you may owe additional premium for the underreported exposure or receive a refund for over-reported exposure. Your insurance company will provide a detailed explanation of any adjustments.

7. Will I be charged for the audit?

Most workers’ compensation policies include the cost of the audit as part of the insurance premium. However, if additional work is required due to poor record-keeping or non-cooperation, there may be extra charges.

8. What if I disagree with the audit findings?

If you disagree with the audit findings, you have the right to dispute them. You should contact your insurance provider to discuss the discrepancies and provide any additional documentation to support your case.

9. How long do I need to keep records for audit purposes?

It’s generally recommended to keep records for at least five years, as audits can look back several years and discrepancies can lead to adjustments for prior periods.

10. Can an audit result in a decrease in my premium?

Yes, if it’s found that you have overestimated your payroll or misclassified employees, you may receive a credit or refund.

11. What happens if I don’t comply with the audit request?

Non-compliance can result in an estimated audit, which often includes a significant additional premium based on assumptions made by the auditor. It can also lead to policy cancellation or non-renewal.

12. Do subcontractors and independent contractors affect my workers’ compensation audit?

Yes, if you use subcontractors or independent contractors, you may need to provide proof that they have their own workers’ compensation insurance, or their payments may be included in your payroll for premium calculation purposes.

13. How is telecommuting or remote work handled in a workers’ compensation audit?

Telecommuting and remote work are generally still covered under workers’ compensation insurance. You’ll need to report the payroll for these employees just as you would for in-office employees.

14. What is a classification code, and why is it important?

A classification code is a numerical designation assigned by the National Council on Compensation Insurance (NCCI) or state rating bureaus that identifies the type of work performed by employees. Accurate classification is crucial as it affects the rate at which your payroll is multiplied to calculate your premium. ( Please see Workers’ Compensation Codes )


Insurance Separator Red Line

Workers’ compensation audits are essential for ensuring the accuracy of premiums paid by employers to workers’ compensation insurance carriers. These audits help verify that the payroll and classification of workers are correct, which can prevent either overpayment or underpayment of premiums. Regular audits protect businesses from unexpected financial liabilities by identifying discrepancies early and help maintain compliance with state laws and regulations. They also serve to deter and detect fraud, thereby contributing to a fairer system for all parties involved.